Heat-Exchanger Network Design for the Atmospheric Distillation Unit at Zawiya Refinery: A Comparison of Pinch Analysis and a Simplified Superstructure Approach
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/bjwzfy38Keywords:
Heat-exchanger network, Pinch analysis, Superstructure, Crude-oil distillation, Energy integrationAbstract
The heat-exchanger network (HEN) of the crude-oil atmospheric distillation unit at Zawiya Refinery, Libya, has received little systematic attention despite several decades of operation. This study compares a pinch-based design with a simplified superstructure approach applied to the same nine-stream data set (six hot and three cold streams). A minimum approach temperature of ΔTmin = 20 °C, identified from the total annual cost (TAC) curve generated with HINT software, gives minimum hot- and cold-utility targets of 23,457.156 kW and 10,882.814 kW, respectively, with pinch temperatures of 126 °C (hot) and 106 °C (cold). Shell targeting on the balanced composite curves, with each 1–2 shell limited to 85% of its maximum thermal effectiveness, gives a target of 29 shells (13 below and 16 above the pinch). The pinch-based network comprises nine process exchangers, one heater and four coolers (14 units), which equals the minimum number of units required for maximum energy recovery. The simplified superstructure, constructed by partitioning the balanced composite curves into eight enthalpy intervals, requires 34 shells before exchanger integration, and its integrated network contains 18 units. Pinch analysis therefore supplies the energy targets and the design constraints, whereas the interval-based superstructure supplies a systematic route to network construction. The hot-utility target is 374 kW (1.6%) below the value reported previously for the same unit; because the cold-utility targets agree, this points to differences in the stream data or net heat balance rather than in ΔTmin. Because capital-cost, heat-transfer-area and operability data are not available for both networks, no economic ranking is attempted.
References
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Alqalam Almoner

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.


